Honey Bees in Trouble

Can native pollinators fill the gap?

A Recently, ominous headlines have described a mysterious ailment, colony collapse disorder, or CCD, that is wiping out the honeybees that pollinate many crops. Without honeybees, the story goes, fields will be sterile, economies will collapse, and food will be scarce.

B But what few accounts acknowledge is that what is at risk is not itself a natural state of affairs. For one thing, in the United States, where CCD was first reported and has had its greatest impact, honeybees are not a native species. Pollination in modern agriculture is not alchemy; it is industry. The total number of hives involved in the US pollination industry has been somewhere between 2.5 million and 3 million in recent years.

Meanwhile, American farmers began using large quantities of organophosphate insecticides, planted large-scale crop monocultures, and adopted "clean farming" practices that scrubbed native vegetation from field margins and roadsides. These practices killed many native bees outright -- they are as vulnerable to insecticides as any agricultural pest -- and made the agricultural landscape inhospitable to those that remained. Concern about these practices and their effects on pollinators is not new. In her 1962 ecological alarm cry Silent Spring, Rachel Carson warned of a "Fruitless Fall" that could result from the disappearance of insect pollinators.

C If that "Fruitless Fall" has not -- yet -- occurred, it may be largely thanks to the honeybee, which farmers turned to as the ability of wild pollinators to service crops declined. The honeybee has been semi-domesticated since the time of the ancient Egyptians, but it was not just familiarity that determined this choice: the bees’ biology is in many ways suited to the kind of agricultural system that was emerging.

For example, honeybee hives can be closed up and moved out of the way when pesticides are applied to a field. The bees are generalist pollinators, so they can be used to pollinate many different crops. And although they are not the most efficient pollinator of every crop, honeybees have strength in numbers, with 20,000 to 100,000 bees living in a single hive.

"Without a doubt, if there was one bee you wanted for agriculture, it would be the honeybee," says Jim Cane of the US Department of Agriculture. The honeybee, in other words, has become a crucial cog in the modern system of industrial agriculture. That system delivers more food, and more kinds of it, to more places, more cheaply than ever before. But that system is also vulnerable, because making a farm field into the photosynthetic equivalent of a factory floor, and pollination into a series of continent-long assembly lines, also leaches out some of the resilience characteristic of natural ecosystems.

D Breno Freitas, an agronomist, pointed out that in nature such a high degree of specialisation is usually a very dangerous game: it works well while everything else is in equilibrium, but runs quickly to extinction at the least imbalance. In effect, by developing an agricultural system that is heavily reliant on a single pollinator species, we humans have become riskily overspecialised. And when the human-honeybee relationship is disrupted, as it has been by colony collapse disorder, the vulnerability of that agricultural system begins to become clear.

E In fact, a few wild bees are already being successfully managed for crop pollination. "The problem is trying to provide native bees in adequate numbers on a reliable basis in a fairly short number of years in order to service the crop," Jim Cane says. "You’re talking millions of flowers per acre in a two- to three-week time frame, or less, for a lot of crops."

On the other hand, native bees can be much more efficient pollinators of certain crops than honeybees, so you do not need as many to do the job. For example, about 750 blue orchard bees, Osmia lignaria, can pollinate a hectare of apples or almonds, a task that would require roughly 50,000 to 150,000 honeybees.

There are bee tinkerers engaged in similar work in many corners of the world. In Brazil, Breno Freitas has found that Centris tarsata, the native pollinator of wild cashew, can survive in commercial cashew orchards if growers provide a source of floral oils, such as by interplanting their cashew trees with Caribbean cherry.

F In certain places, native bees may already be doing more than they are getting credit for. Ecologist Rachael Winfree recently led a team that looked at pollination of four summer crops -- tomato, watermelon, peppers and muskmelon -- at 29 farms in the region of New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Winfree’s team identified 54 species of wild bees that visited these crops, and found that wild bees were the most important pollinators in the system: even though managed honeybees were present on many of the farms, wild bees were responsible for 62 percent of flower visits in the study.

In another study focusing specifically on watermelon, Winfree and her colleagues calculated that native bees alone could provide sufficient pollination at 90 percent of the 23 farms studied. By contrast, honeybees alone could provide sufficient pollination at only 78 percent of farms.

G "The region I work in is not typical of the way most food is produced," Winfree admits. In the Delaware Valley, most farms and farm fields are relatively small, each farmer typically grows a variety of crops, and farms are interspersed with suburbs and other types of land use, which means there are opportunities for homeowners to get involved in bee conservation, too.

The landscape is a bee-friendly patchwork that provides a variety of nesting habitats and floral resources distributed among different kinds of crops, weedy field margins, fallow fields, suburban neighbourhoods and semi-natural habitats like old woodlots, all at a relatively small scale. In other words, "pollinator-friendly" farming practices would not only aid pollination of agricultural crops, but also serve as a key element in the overall conservation strategy for wild pollinators, and often aid other wild species as well.

H Of course, not all farmers will be able to implement all of these practices. And researchers are suggesting a shift to a kind of polyglot agricultural system. For some small-scale farms, native bees may indeed be all that is needed. For larger operations, a suite of managed bees -- with honeybees filling the generalist role and other native bees pollinating specific crops -- could be augmented by free pollination services from resurgent wild pollinators. In other words, they are saying, we still have an opportunity to replace a risky monoculture with something diverse, resilient and robust.